Idyllwild Town Crier
   


 

News & Features
From the Idyllwild Town Crier weekly newspaper, 06.18.09 edition.



Pine Cove wants to end Water Agency


By J.P. Crumrine, News Editor


The Pine Cove Water District (PCWD) finally expressed its frustration with the Mt. San Jacinto Water Study Agency (WSA). With President Thomas McCullough leading, the board sent a letter to both the Fern Valley and Idyllwild water districts recommending that the trio terminate their joint power agency, the WSA.

In the letter, PCWD enumerated six reasons for ending the formal relationship among the three water districts. However, PCWD was careful not to adopt an isolationist position. The letter begins with an affirmation of the district’s willingness to support mutual aid agreements between the water agencies.

The WSA’s original purpose, a joint waste treatment facility for the Hill, has never been realized and that is McCullough’s first point. He also noted that the WSA’s 2005 Resource Management Plan was not unanimously embraced. Finally, the original incorporation agreement established a Dec. 31, 2013 sunset date. PCWD is suggesting an earlier end to the hobbled agency.

However, the recent proposal to expand the WSA’s mission to “construct, own and operate domestic water and wastewater facilities” revived the specter of an old wound or irritant — consolidation.

While McCullough and his colleagues did not raise this old ghost, Nancy Borchers, Pine Cove resident and former president of the property owners association, described the proposed expanded mission as “an end run around consolidation.”

“Water czar,” is Director Lou Padula’s interpretation of the proposed mission expansion.

While PCWD acknowledges that they and IWD share wells at Dutch Flats, the board has no interest in expanding the number of wells it shares with other districts.

"PCWD believes that a joint operation of additional water production facilities involving all three districts would be cumbersome, inefficient and unnecessarily expensive,” according to its letter.

WSA’s future purpose was to be discussed at its meeting last week; however because various versions of the language were circulating among the members, the topic was postponed until the September meeting.

Marge Muir, Pine Cove resident and local real estate broker, also attended the PCWD meeting and spoke more sympathetically about the WSA. She made two points to the directors.

First a WSA meeting, regardless of frequency, offered a forum to discuss and possibly collaborate on common Hill water issues. Secondly, she expressed concern about the future advent of strong septic system regulations coming from the state to the county.

In response, McCullough said that the current agreement does not address septic systems. If the need for cooperation or common regulation occurs, the districts can address the matter then. Even so, that event may occur beyond the sunset date.

“It’s a good letter and I’m glad you emphasized cooperation,” Director Mike Esnard said before the vote, which was unanimous.

J.P. Crumrine can be reached at jp@towncrier.com.
 
 



Web Site designed by the Idyllwild Town Crier © 1995-2007 by Idyllwild Publications

WEBMASTER